
The Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher has some of the boldest contaminant reduction claims of any water filter pitcher we’ve tested: up to 99.99% removal of 365+ contaminants. But how does it perform in a real-world situation?
We’ve recently retested this filter after two important changes to the product since our last tests: its NSF/ANSI Standard 53 certification for PFOA and PFOS has lapsed, and Clearly Filtered has redesigned the pitcher. After putting it through the same series of assessments, our scores have changed. We’ll be sharing all the differences in this review.
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
| Price | $100 |
| Contaminants Reduced | 365+ (manufacturer claim) |
| Certifications | NSF/ANSI 42 & 372 |
| Holding Capacity | 10 Cups |
| Filter Lifespan | 100 gallons |
| Annual Cost | $200.75 |
| Warranty | 2 years |
Quick Verdict: Is the Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher Worth It?
The Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher earned an overall score of 8.01/10 after our second and third Tap Score lab tests in July 2026, down from 8.78/10 in our 2024 test of the previous design. It removed 100% of the fluoride, uranium, lead, and total THMs detected above Health Guideline Levels in our water, but cobalt that was absent from our feed water appeared in the filtered water in all three tests (0.0054, 0.0159, and 0.0079 PPM), its measured filtration rate fell from 2.27 GPH to 0.97 GPH, and its NSF/ANSI Standard 53 certification for PFOA and PFOS has lapsed. Chlorine taste and odor (NSF/ANSI 42) is now its only certified reduction claim out of 365+ advertised. It remains one of our picks in our roundup of the best water filter pitchers, but no longer at the top.
Buy it if: Your water contains fluoride, uranium, lead, or disinfection byproducts and you want a filter that addresses them with no installation, which also makes it convenient if you rent or move often. You will need to be comfortable relying on manufacturer-commissioned testing rather than certification for most of its 365+ claims.
Skip it if: You want fast access to filtered water (a full reservoir took roughly 31 minutes in our testing), you are shopping on a budget ($100 upfront, $0.55 per gallon, around $200.75 per year), or you are buying specifically for certified PFAS reduction, because the previous PFOA/PFOS certification is no longer current. Many third-party reviews and seller pages still list it.
Methodology: See exactly how we test and score water filters in our testing methodology. Contaminant reduction is weighted at 55% of the overall score.
📊 Scoring Data
At Water Filter Guru, we use data from our hands-on testing and subjective analysis to evaluate water filters for our reviews.
Our detailed scoring system weighs multiple performance factors to give a balanced overall rating for each filter we test. With this data, we can easily compare all the similar water filters we’ve tested, giving us a fair side-by-side comparison.
See the next table to learn how the Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher performed against other water filter pitchers we’ve put through the same testing process.
| Criteria | Results |
|---|---|
| Health Related Contaminants | 7.27 |
| Aesthetic Related Contaminants | 9.90 |
| Performance Certification | Certified for 0.27% of reduction claims (1 of 365+) |
| Filtration Rate | 0.97 GPH |
| Component Quality | Outstanding |
| Component Certification | Certified |
| Setup | Outstanding |
| Servicing Requirements | Outstanding |
| Costs | $0.55/ gallon |
| Warranty Length | 2 years |
| Shipping | Free shipping with autoship subscription only |
| Returns | 30 days |
We first lab-tested this pitcher in 2024, when it received a score of 8.78. This review reflects our second and third lab tests, completed in July 2026.
🚱 How Well Does the Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher Remove Contaminants?
Score: 7.36Key Finding: In our second Tap Score lab test, the Clearly Filtered pitcher removed 100% of fluoride, uranium, and lead from our feed water, but 0.0159 PPM of cobalt appeared in the filtered water (not detected in our baseline sample), the second time this has happened with this filter. A third test with a brand-new filter (the test 2 filter had been in storage) produced 0.0079 PPM of cobalt post-filtration, less than test 2 but still roughly 4x Tap Score’s 0.002 PPM screening level.
What Was Our Test Water Quality Like?
In our two additional retests of the redesigned Clearly Filtered pitcher conducted in July 2026, our test water was challenging, with a TDS reading of 807 PPM (in test 2) and 803 PPM (in test 3), 314 PPM hardness (in test 2) and 307 PPM hardness (in test 3), and a pH of 8.0 (in both tests).
We can see from this data alone that our feed water in both 2026 tests was substantially harder and higher in dissolved solids than the water used in our first test, which had a TDS reading of 137 PPM and 90 PPM of hardness.
The concentrations of certain contaminants also differed significantly between our 2024 and 2026 tests, so we won’t be comparing percentage reductions between them unless the starting concentrations were similar. Only fluoride, nitrate, cobalt, and uranium meet that requirement.
Test 2
In test 2, a number of contaminants exceeding the Health Guideline Level were detected in our Tap Score report:
- 0.0044 PPM (parts per million) lead (exceeding the HGL of 0)
- 1 PPM fluoride (exceeding the HGL of 0.799 PPM)
- 0.0152 PPM uranium (exceeding the HGL of 0)
- 3.93 PPB (parts per billion) bromoform (exceeding the HGL of 0)
- 4.15 PPB dibromochloromethane (exceeding the HGL of 0.1 PPB)
- 0.488 PPM copper (exceeding the HGL of 0.3 PPM)
Several contaminants were also detected in levels not exceeding the HGL, including boron, barium, sulfate, vanadium, selenium, nickel, manganese, nitrate, strontium, total chromium, and molybdenum.
Here’s a detailed look at what was present in our test 2 baseline sample:
| Contaminant | Measurement | Pre-Filtration | Post-Filtration | % Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alkalinity (as CaCO3) | PPM | 370 | 315 | -14.86% |
| Barium | PPM | 0.0311 | 0.00202 | -93.50% |
| Bicarbonate | PPM | 447 | 382 | -14.54% |
| Boron | PPM | 0.378 | 0.437 | 15.61% |
| Bromoform | PPB | 3.93 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Calcium | PPM | 94.1 | 67 | -28.80% |
| Carbonate | PPM | 2.06 | 1.11 | -46.12% |
| Chloride | PPM | 113 | 114 | 0.88% |
| Chloride-to-Sulfate Mass Ratio | 0.543 | 0.655 | 20.63% | |
| Chromium (Total) | PPM | 0.00413 | 0.00383 | -7.26% |
| Copper | PPM | 0.488 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Dibromochloromethane | PPB | 4.15 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Expanded Hardness | PPM | 316 | 264 | -16.46% |
| Fluoride | PPM | 1 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Grains per gallon | Grains | 18.3 | 15.4 | -15.85% |
| Hardness | PPM | 314 | 263 | -16.24% |
| Langelier Saturation Index | 0.864 | 0.453 | -47.57% | |
| Lead | PPM | 0.0044 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Magnesium | PPM | 19.2 | 23.3 | 21.35% |
| Manganese | PPM | 0.00136 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Molybdenum | PPM | 0.00119 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Nickel | PPM | 0.00106 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Nitrate (as N) | PPM | 3.7 | 3.6 | -2.70% |
| pH | pH | 8 | 7.8 | -2.50% |
| Potassium | PPM | 3.65 | 3.79 | 3.84% |
| Selenium | PPM | 0.00543 | 0.00413 | -23.94% |
| Sodium | PPM | 162 | 168 | 3.70% |
| Sodium Adsorption Ratio | 3.97 | 4.5 | 13.35% | |
| Specific Conductivity | umhos/cm | 1390 | 1200 | -13.67% |
| Strontium | PPM | 0.969 | 0.273 | -71.83% |
| Sulfate | PPM | 208 | 174 | -16.35% |
| Total Dissolved Solids | PPM | 807 | 697 | -13.63% |
| Total THMs | PPB | 8.08 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Uranium | PPM | 0.0152 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Vanadium | PPM | 0.0015 | 0.000945 | -37.00% |
Test 3
In test 3, the following contaminants exceeded the HGL:
- 1.7 PPM fluoride (exceeding the HGL of 0.799 PPM)
- 0.0148 PPM uranium (exceeding the HGL of 0)
- 4.27 PPB bromodichloromethane (exceeding the HGL of 0)
- 3.41 PPB bromoform (exceeding the HGL of 0)
- 8.82 PPB dibromochloromethane (exceeding the HGL of 0.1 PPB)
- 0.777 PPM copper (exceeding the HGL of 0.3 PPM)
Those that didn’t exceed the HGL include total chromium, molybdenum, nitrate, selenium, strontium, sulfate, and vanadium.
Here’s what our test 3 baseline sample contained:
| Contaminant | Measurement | Pre-Filtration | Post-Filtration | % Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alkalinity (as CaCO3) | PPM | 354 | 323 | -8.76% |
| Barium | PPM | 0.0327 | 0.00132 | -95.96% |
| Bicarbonate | PPM | 428 | 391 | -8.64% |
| Boron | PPM | 0.375 | 0.376 | 0.27% |
| Bromodichloromethane | PPB | 4.27 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Bromoform | PPB | 3.41 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Calcium | PPM | 91.4 | 71.9 | -21.33% |
| Carbonate | PPM | 1.97 | 1.43 | -27.41% |
| Chloride | PPM | 107 | 108 | 0.93% |
| Chloride-to-Sulfate Mass Ratio | 0.572 | 0.6 | 4.90% | |
| Chromium (Total) | PPM | 0.0032 | 0.00268 | -16.25% |
| Copper | PPM | 0.777 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Dibromochloromethane | PPB | 8.82 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Expanded Hardness | PPM | 310 | 261 | -15.81% |
| Fluoride | PPM | 1.7 | 0.3 | -82.35% |
| Grains per gallon | Grains | 18 | 15.2 | -15.56% |
| Hardness | PPM | 307 | 261 | -14.98% |
| Langelier Saturation Index | 0.832 | 0.592 | -28.85% | |
| Magnesium | PPM | 19.2 | 19.7 | 2.60% |
| Molybdenum | PPM | 0.0012 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Nitrate (as N) | PPM | 4.1 | 3.9 | -4.88% |
| pH | pH | 8 | 7.9 | -1.25% |
| Potassium | PPM | 3.39 | 3.17 | -6.49% |
| Selenium | PPM | 0.00535 | 0.00358 | -33.08% |
| Sodium | PPM | 162 | 161 | -0.62% |
| Sodium Adsorption Ratio | 4.02 | 4.33 | 7.71% | |
| Specific Conductivity | umhos/cm | 1380 | 1260 | -8.70% |
| Strontium | PPM | 0.979 | 0.646 | -34.01% |
| Sulfate | PPM | 187 | 180 | -3.74% |
| Total Dissolved Solids | PPM | 803 | 731 | -8.97% |
| Total THMs | PPB | 16.5 | 0 | -100.00% |
| Uranium | PPM | 0.0148 | 0.000917 | -93.80% |
| Vanadium | PPM | 0.00126 | 0 | -100.00% |
Which Contaminants Did The Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher Remove?
We recorded some strong results in our second and third lab tests of the Clearly Filtered pitcher. It greatly reduced or completely removed a handful of contaminants, including every single contaminant that was initially detected in concentrations exceeding the HGL.
We’ve listed all the contaminants that the pitcher eliminated below.
Fluoride
In test 2, 1.0 PPM of fluoride was initially detected in our baseline sample, exceeding the HGL of 0.799 PPM. Post-filtration, fluoride had been reduced down to 0, representing a complete elimination.
In our 2024 test and our first 2026 test, the pitcher completely removed fluoride down to undetectable levels when it was initially detected in similar concentrations (1.1 PPM in 2024, and 1 PPM in 2026).
Test 3’s baseline concentrations of fluoride were higher, at 1.7 PPM. This time, an 82.35% reduction was recorded, down to 0.3 PPM.
Uranium
Uranium was another contaminant detected above the Health Guideline Level in test 2: 0.0152 PPM was present in our feed water, exceeding the HGL of 0. This was eliminated down to 0 after filtration in the Clearly Filtered pitcher.
As with fluoride, we can directly compare our 2024 test with our first 2026 test for uranium removal because similar concentrations were detected in both: 0.014 PPM in our 2024 test, and 0.0152 PPM detected pre-filtration in 2026. Both times, uranium was completely removed by the filter.
When we conducted our retest in 2026 with a fresh filter, uranium levels were similar again in our baseline sample: 0.0148 PPM. This time, the pitcher reduced uranium by 93.80%, to 0.000917 PPM.
Lead
In our first 2026 test, our unfiltered water contained 0.0044 PPM lead. This is another contaminant that has an HGL of 0. The Clearly Filtered pitcher removed it completely from our water, down to undetectable levels.
When we tested the filter again, lead wasn’t detected pre- or post-filtration. It also hadn’t been detected in our 2024 water samples.
Disinfection Byproducts
When we initially tested the Clearly Filtered pitcher in 2026, our baseline sample contained 2 disinfection byproducts in the THMs group: 3.93 PPB bromoform (exceeding the HGL of 0), 4.15 PPB dibromochloromethane (exceeding the HGL of 0.1 PPB); a combined concentration of 8.08 PPB. Both were completely removed from our post-filtration sample.
In our 2026 retest with a brand-new, just-purchased filter, our feed water contained 3 DBPs: 3.41 PPB of bromoform, 4.27 PPB of bromodichloromethane, and 8.82 PPB of dibromochloromethane. Post-filtration, these were all eliminated completely.
Looking back at when we first tested the previous iteration of the pitcher in 2024, no disinfection byproducts were detected before or after filtration.
Copper
In test 2, 0.488 PPM copper was initially detected in our feed water, exceeding the HGL of 0.3 PPM. After filtering through the Clearly Filtered pitcher, copper was no longer detected, demonstrating a complete removal.
When we retested the pitcher later in the same month, 0.777 PPM of copper was detected, which was once again reduced to 0 post-filtration.
0.163 PPM of copper had been detected in our 2024 test, and again, the previous iteration of the Clearly Filtered model had removed it completely.
Nickel
Our lab report for test 2 shows 0.00106 PPM nickel in our unfiltered water, reduced down to undetectable levels post-filtration: a 100% elimination.
Nickel wasn’t detected in either water sample in our initial 2024 test or in our 2026 newly-purchased filter retest.
Manganese
In test 2, trace levels of manganese were detected in our baseline sample; around 0.00136 PPM. Post-filtration, no manganese was detected.
Manganese didn’t show up in our water pre- or post-filtration in test 1 or test 3.
Molybdenum
Molybdenum was another contaminant present in trace concentrations before filtration. In test 2, the Clearly Filtered pitcher brought it down from 0.00119 PPM to 0: another complete elimination. We also saw a 100% reduction in test 3, from 0.0012 PPM to 0.
Looking back at our first lab test of Clearly Filtered in 2024, the pitcher was only able to reduce molybdenum by 53.85%, from 0.0026 PPM in our feed water to 0.0012 PPM post-filtration.
Chlorine
Chlorine is the only contaminant that this pitcher is certified to remove. In our on-site chlorine testing in test 2, our feedwater sample contained 1.56 PPM of free chlorine, and this was reduced to just 0 post-filtration: a 100% reduction.

This is consistent with our first test in 2024, where the previous iteration of the Clearly Filtered pitcher also eliminated chlorine from 1 PPM to 0.
Barium & Strontium
When we tested the Clearly Filtered pitcher in 2026, it reduced barium by 93.50% (from 0.0311 PPM to 0.00202 PPM), and strontium by 71.83% (from 0.969 PPM to 0.273 PPM).
When reducing barium, it performed similarly in test 3: the lab report documents a 95.96% reduction (from 0.0327 PPM to 0.00132 PPM). But its strontium performance was worse: it only reduced this contaminant by 34.01% (from 0.979 PPM to 0.646 PPM).
If we look back to 2024, barium reduction was again consistent: an 86.08% reduction, from 0.0158 PPM initially to 0.0022 PPM post-filtration. Strontium was reduced by 67.27%, closer to our test 3 reductions, from 0.11 PPM to 0.036 PPM.
In all three tests, these weren’t complete eliminations, but they’re still significant reductions worth highlighting.
What Did the Clearly Filtered Pitcher Struggle To Remove?
Some of the contaminants detected in our baseline sample were only reduced slightly by the Clearly Filtered pitcher:
| Contaminant | Test 2 Reduction | Test 3 Reduction | 2024 Test Reduction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vanadium | 37.00% (0.0015 → 0.000945 PPM) | 100% (0.00126 → 0 PPM) | Not detected before or after filtration |
| Selenium | 23.94% (0.00543 → 0.00413 PPM) | 33.08% (0.00535 → 0.00358 PPM) | Not detected before or after filtration |
| Sulfate | 16.35% (208 → 174 PPM) | 3.74% (187 → 180 PPM) | 3.57% (8.4 → 8.1 PPM) |
| Total chromium | 7.26% (0.00413 → 0.00383 PPM) | 16.25% (0.0032 → 0.00268 PPM) | Not detected before or after filtration |
| Nitrate | 2.70% (3.7 → 3.6 PPM) | 4.88% (4.1 → 3.9 PPM) | 11.43% (3.5 → 3.1 PPM) |
Most likely, the reductions in chromium and nitrate were simply due to incidental differences in our water between tests, rather than a direct result of filtration in the Clearly Filtered pitcher.
The pitcher isn’t certified to reduce any of these contaminants, but the manufacturer’s independent lab results list the following reductions:
- 97.50% vanadium
- 98.77% strontium
- 99.88% sulfate
- 99.68% hexavalent chromium*
- >99.93% nitrate and nitrite
This data isn’t consistent with our own results. Our test water most likely had different TDS, hardness, alkalinity, and specific contaminant concentrations than Clearly Filtered’s independent lab’s. But we would still expect to see results much closer to Clearly Filtered’s claims.
Were There Any Anomalies?
There were a couple of anomalies with our retests of the Clearly Filtered pitcher.
First, in test 2, boron increased by 15.61%, from 0.378 PPM to 0.437 PPM. While this might seem unusual, the concentrations (both in the initial and filtered water samples) are so low that a 15% increase is likely just incidental. We don’t believe the filter itself was responsible.
We saw a much smaller 0.27% increase in boron in test 3 (with a just-purchased filter, rather than one that was in storage), from 0.375 PPM to 0.376 PPM. Boron wasn’t detected in our initial 2024 tests.
But a result that we do associate with the filter is the increase in cobalt. This result concerns us most because we’ve now seen the same pattern in all three independent lab tests.
| Test | Boron (pre to post) | Cobalt (pre to post) |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 test | Not detected in either sample | Not detected to 0.0054 PPM |
| 2026 test 2 | 0.378 to 0.437 PPM | Not detected to 0.0159 PPM |
| 2026 test 3 | 0.375 to 0.376 PPM | Not detected to 0.0079 PPM |
In 2024, cobalt was non-detectable in our feed water, but measured 0.0054 PPM after filtration. At the time, we said that we couldn’t explain the result and intended to do a retest, which we have now done.
In our first 2026 test, cobalt was, again, non-detectable in our baseline sample. After filtration, our test lab measured 0.0159 PPM in the water.
Tap Score uses a health-based screening level of 0.002 PPM for cobalt, putting our test 2 post-filtration concentration at around 8x that benchmark. This concentration was also roughly 3x the concentration of 0.0054 PPM detected in our 2024 test.
Our test 2 filter had been in storage before we used it, so we purchased a new filter and conducted a third test to see if this would make a difference. But we saw the same pattern again: cobalt was initially not detected, but increased to 0.0079 PPM post-filtration.
We don’t know why cobalt appeared in our filtered water, and we don’t want to speculate on a possible cause. We can only report on what our data shows: that cobalt was absent from our feed water and detected post-filtration in our 2024 and 2026 tests.
Other Results Worth Mentioning
Minerals and pH
We also saw different mineral and pH behavior between the two generations of the Clearly Filtered pitcher.
In our 2024 lab test, pH increased from 7.4 to 8.0. Magnesium increased by 64.56%, sodium by 48.49%, and potassium also increased.

In our initial 2026 test, pH actually fell from 8.0 to 7.8, while magnesium increased less significantly, by 21.35%. Sodium and potassium barely increased at all: sodium by 3.70% and potassium by 3.84%.
Similarly, in test 3, pH dropped from 8.0 to 7.9, and magnesium increased by 2.60%, from 19.2 PPM to 19.7 PPM. Sodium decreased by 0.62%, and potassium by 6.49%.
The mineral-exchanging behavior is clearly different between the 2024 and 2026 filters we tested. This could have been influenced by a change in the filter media used, a difference in our feed water conditions, or (most likely) a combination of the two.
Our Field Testing
Alongside our lab testing, in test 2, we also took our own field measurements for chlorine, hardness, and TDS.
Our field photometer measured 1.56 PPM of free chlorine before filtration, and 0 PPM afterwards: a 100% reduction. Hardness was also completely eliminated according to our field photometer.
TDS fell from 679 PPM to 632 PPM, a reduction of 6.9%. Our field-measured pH reading increased slightly, from 7.8 to 8.0.

These are our field measurements and are separate from the lab results we’ve reported on above.
Is the Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher Performance-Certified?
Score: 7.00
Key Finding: Since our first review, Clearly Filtered’s NSF/ANSI Standard 53 certification for PFOA and PFOS reduction has lapsed. The pitcher is now only certified to NSF/ANSI Standard 42 for chlorine taste and odor, which is 1 certified reduction claim out of the 365+ contaminants the manufacturer says it reduces.
When we published our initial review of the Clearly Filtered pitcher, it held an NSF/ANSI 42 certification for chlorine taste and odor, as well as an NSF/ANSI 53 certification for PFOA and PFOS reduction.
We checked the certification listings when writing this update, and we could see that the Standard 53 certification is no longer active. The pitcher is currently only listed with both the WQA and NSF for NSF/ANSI Standard 42, for chlorine taste and odor reduction.
That means it has just 1 certified contaminant reduction claim against its 365+ advertised claims (under 1%). This resulted in a score of 7.00 for performance certifications in our scoring system, where certification accounts for 10% of the contaminant reduction score.
Clearly Filtered’s other reduction claims are supported by third-party testing by QFT, a division of IAPMO, commissioned by the manufacturer. Third-party testing isn’t the same as product certification, which has far more rigorous requirements.
We’ve never lab tested the pitcher for PFAS because our Tap Score panel doesn’t include PFAS analytes. That means there’s neither a current certification nor our own test data to document or evaluate the filter’s PFAS performance.
🚦Filtration Speed
Score: 7.50Key Finding: The Clearly Filtered pitcher took 30 minutes and 39 seconds to filter a full 63.14-ounce reservoir in our tests, which gives us a measured filtration rate of 0.97 GPH (gallons per hour). That’s down from the 2.27 GPH filtration rate we measured in our first test.
We measured Clearly Filtered’s filtration rate by timing the process of filtering a full reservoir of water, then converting this to a gallons-per-hour reading.
At a feed water temperature of 73.3°F, we filled the upper reservoir to the fill line, then started the timer. Our standard testing protocol involves timing three full reservoir fills, but for this test, due to how long the process took, we only timed one fill.
A single fill took 30 minutes and 39 seconds, which converts to a filtration rate of 0.97 GPH. Clearly Filtered was the second-slowest of the 7 filter pitchers we tested in this 2026 cohort.
Slower gravity filtration has its benefits: dense filter media and longer contact give water more time to interact with the filtration media. But from a practical standpoint, not everyone wants to wait over half an hour for a single reservoir to fill, especially if you have a bigger family.
Plus, in our test, this additional contact time didn’t translate into a stronger reduction across every contaminant. For example, in test 2, nitrate was reduced by just 2.70%, while in our 2024 test with the faster 2.27 GPH filtration rate, it was reduced by 11.43%. Not a great result in either test, but it demonstrates that when a filter is unable to effectively address a contaminant, prolonging the contact time with the media won’t make a difference.
We don’t think this is a dealbreaker for most folks, but to avoid a long wait for your water, we recommend filling the pitcher first thing in the morning, then topping up the reservoir throughout the day as you use the filtered water. That should make the slower 0.97 GPH filtration rate less disruptive.
📐 Design and Usability
Score: 9.70Key Finding: The redesigned Clearly Filtered pitcher is made from Tritan plastic and certified to NSF/ANSI 372 for lead-free materials, earning a perfect 10.00 for materials certification. But this new design carries over the same issue we identified with the original pitcher: the upper reservoir can move out of place and leak from the lid seam if you pour while it still contains unfiltered water.
In our 2024 review of Clearly Filtered’s design, we noted that the pitcher felt better-made, more solid, and more durable than the majority of the similar products we’d tested.

In this 2026 review, we’ve tested the redesigned generation of the Clearly Filtered pitcher, so the new model’s hardware isn’t identical to the pitcher from our first test. The biggest improvement we noticed is the flip lid, which is now attached to the upper reservoir rather than being a separate piece, so it doesn’t fall off.
The pitcher received a score of 9.50 for its component quality. It’s made from Tritan plastic, which is BPA- and BPS-free, along with a sealed composite filter cartridge. As with our original test of the 2024 model, we noted that this redesigned version felt higher-quality than those used by many of the other pitchers in our testing cohort.
We did find the filter threads somewhat difficult to seat correctly with a tight seal, so take care when you’re installing a new cartridge.
Clearly Filtered’s capacity is one of its design strengths. We measured 63.0 ounces of usable filtered water and just 0.1 ounces of dead volume, which gives it a 99.8% usable volume ratio: the best in our 2026 testing cohort.
The pitcher weighs 3.00 pounds when it’s empty and 6.85 pounds when full of water. It had the largest footprint of our recent pitcher cohort, although it still fits in a standard fridge door.

We also found it easy to handle and pour with one hand, and it scored 10/10 in our dribble test, as we didn’t notice any water running down the outside of the pitcher while pouring.
Were There Any Design Issues?
There was one design issue that hasn’t been fixed with this new-generation Clearly Filtered model: when you pour out the last of the water from the bottom reservoir, the upper reservoir can move out of place.
If there’s still water waiting to be filtered in the upper reservoir, that means water can leak from the lid seam as you pour. As a result, unfiltered water is able to bypass the filter and enter your glass.
You can avoid this bypass by waiting until the upper reservoir has completely drained before you pour, but we do think Clearly Filtered should have addressed this problem in its redesign.
Is the Clearly Filtered Pitcher Design Certified?
The Clearly Filtered pitcher has a WQA certification to NSF/ANSI Standard 372 for lead-free design.
That means the pitcher has been tested and certified to meet the minimum requirements for the evaluation of lead content in its materials and components, confirming that it complies with laws, regulations, and other restrictions for lead content.
The model we tested in 2024 held a materials safety certification as a component of its NSF 42 and 53 performance certifications. The new model holds the same certification as part of its NSF 42 certification.
⚙️ Setup
Score: 9.50Key Finding: It took us 25 minutes to set up the Clearly Filtered pitcher from unboxing to having our first batch of usable filtered water. Most of that time was spent waiting for the first full reservoir of water to filter rather than preparing the filter itself.
The setup process for the Clearly Filtered pitcher was pretty easy, with no filter pre-soaking or flushing required. Our box contained a priming bag that we used to force water through the cartridge before installing it. Make sure you keep hold of the priming bag after setup because you can reuse it when you’re priming replacement filters.

The priming process does require more effort than we expected. You need real hand strength to seat the bag firmly against the filter, and water leaked from the top unless we tightened the connection hard. While it might have meant we could avoid the conventional soak-and-flush process used by many other filter pitchers, we found the priming process more annoying.
Here’s how we set up the pitcher:
- First, we washed the pitcher and reservoir.
- We then primed the filter. This involved attaching the reusable priming bag to the filter, filling it with water, and squeezing the water through the cartridge.
- Once the filter was primed, we installed it into the pitcher by screwing it into the upper reservoir.
- Next, we assembled and filled the pitcher with cold water.
- We then left the reservoir to filter completely. Clearly Filtered doesn’t instruct you to discard this first batch, but we do so as part of our standard testing procedure.
After this, we discarded the first batch, and the pitcher was ready to provide usable filtered water.
The instructions that came with the pitcher were easy to follow, scoring 9/10, although there’s missing information on whether the first batch of water can be used straight away or should be discarded.
In all, our total measured setup time was 25 minutes from unboxing to first usable filtered water, and filtering the first batch of water was the biggest factor here.
🔧 Maintenance
Score: 8.75Key Finding: Each replacement filter is rated for 100 gallons, or about 4 months, and costs $55, which works out to $0.55 per gallon or an estimated $200.75 per year at 1 gallon per day. Of the 13 pitchers in our cost comparison, only the Epic Pure XP ($0.59), Culligan ZeroWater ($0.93), and LARQ PureVis Advanced ($0.94) cost more per gallon.
How Much Do the Replacement Filters Cost?
Score: 8.00
At the time of writing this review, the Clearly Filtered pitcher has an upfront cost of $100, and individual replacement filters cost $55 each.
With the filters rated for 100 gallons, that works out at a cost per gallon of $0.55. If you filter one gallon of water per day, you’d use around 3.7 filters per year, which gives you an estimated annual filter replacement cost of $200.75, and a 5-year filter cost of $1,003.75.
Here’s how Clearly Filtered’s ongoing filter replacement cost compares with other filter pitchers we’ve tested.
| Water Filter Pitcher | Filter Life (Gallons) | Replacement Filter Cost | Cost per Gallon | Estimated Annual Filter Cost | Estimated 5-Year Filter Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amazon Basics | 40 | $3.50 | $0.09 | $31.94 | $159.69 |
| Brita Standard (Pitcher) | 40 | $7.99 | $0.20 | $72.91 | $364.54 |
| Nakii | 150 | $8.33 | $0.06 | $20.27 | $101.35 |
| PUR Basic (Pitcher) | 40 | $8.50 | $0.21 | $77.56 | $387.81 |
| Waterdrop PT-07B | 200 | $9.75 | $0.05 | $17.79 | $88.97 |
| Aarke | 31.7 | $10.00 | $0.32 | $115.14 | $575.71 |
| PUR Plus (Pitcher) | 40 | $13.77 | $0.34 | $125.65 | $628.26 |
| Culligan ZeroWater | 20 | $18.50 | $0.93 | $337.63 | $1,688.13 |
| Brita Elite (Pitcher) | 120 | $19.99 | $0.17 | $60.80 | $304.01 |
| Santevia MINA | 80 | $26.99 | $0.34 | $123.14 | $615.71 |
| Clearly Filtered Pitcher | 100 | $55.00 | $0.55 | $200.75 | $1,003.75 |
| LARQ PureVis Advanced | 60 | $56.26 | $0.94 | $342.25 | $1,711.24 |
| Epic Pure XP | 100 | $59.00 | $0.59 | $215.35 | $1,076.75 |
Clearly Filtered sits towards the expensive end of the pitchers we’ve tested. Of the 13 pitchers in the table above, only the Epic Pure XP ($0.59 per gallon), the Culligan ZeroWater ($0.93), and the LARQ PureVis Advanced ($0.94) cost more to run.
You can bring the price down if you buy multi-packs of replacement filters instead of buying each filter individually. This is worth doing if you know you’ll keep using the pitcher long-term.
Is The Clearly Filtered Pitcher Easy to Maintain?
Like the majority of the pitchers we’ve tested so far, the Clearly Filtered doesn’t have much ongoing maintenance to deal with, and the servicing tasks themselves are easy.
The pitcher uses a single filter cartridge that’s rated for 100 gallons (around 4 months), so you don’t have the hassle of multiple filtration stages to replace on different schedules.

That said, it’s not the absolute easiest-to-maintain pitcher we’ve tested owing to the fact that there’s no countdown timer or filter life indicator on the jug or lid. You’ll need to make a recurring reminder (we recommend setting one on your phone) so you don’t lose track of when the 4-month replacement point is nearing.
Every replacement filter also needs to be primed using the reusable priming bag, which, as we mentioned in our setup comments, is annoyingly strenuous to use.

🏢Company, Warranty, & Returns
Score: 8.40Key Finding: Clearly Filtered offers a 24-month warranty and a 30-day satisfaction guarantee, but you’ll need to pay shipping fees unless you sign up for the autoship subscription.
Does Clearly Filtered Offer a Warranty?
The Clearly Filtered pitcher comes with a 24-month warranty, earning it a score of 9.00 in this subcategory. This warranty applies specifically to products that were purchased directly from Clearly Filtered, not if you buy through another retailer.
According to the warranty page, each product is inspected for defects before shipping, which should, in theory, reduce the likelihood of needing to make a warranty claim. But if you receive a defective item due to unexpected faulty workmanship or materials, the warranty may allow you to receive a replacement.
What Are Clearly Filtered’s Shipping and Returns Policies?
In our original 2024 review, we mentioned that Clearly Filtered offers free shipping to everywhere in the US, with no minimum order value required.
But the company has since updated its shipping policy, and now, free shipping is only available if you sign up for the autoship subscription. This change has pulled the shipping subcategory score down from 10.00 to 8.00
As for returns, every order is backed by a 30-day satisfaction guarantee. This is a step above the standard “returns policy”, as it allows you to return your pitcher for a full refund within this 30-day window if “for any reason you are not in love with your new Clearly Filtered product”.
It’s nearly a perfect guarantee, but your original shipping fees will be excluded from the refund, and you’ll be expected to pay the return shipping fees, which pulls the returns score down to 8.00.
🤔 Final Verdict: Does the Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher Offer Good Value for Money?
After our second and third rounds of lab testing, the Clearly Filtered pitcher ranks 8th of the 15 water filter pitchers we have scored, with an overall score of 8.01. That means 7 of the other water filter pitchers we tested received higher overall scores, with our winner, the Culligan ZeroWater, earning a score of 9.33.
One of the biggest questions that our latest results have raised is: does Clearly Filtered still justify its price? At $100 upfront and around $200.75 per year in replacement filters, its overall performance puts it below cheaper filter pitchers like the $25.50 Amazon Basics pitcher (which scored 8.79) and the $20 Waterdrop PT-07B (which scored 8.15).
Clearly Filtered’s main selling point is that it claims to reduce a much broader range of contaminants. But according to our recent 2026 lab tests, the filter doesn’t actually perform better on the whole than many similar pitchers with a much smaller list of advertised reduction claims.
That doesn’t mean you should definitely avoid Clearly Filtered, though. Of all the pitchers we lab tested, it’s still the strongest option specifically for addressing fluoride, uranium, lead, and disinfection byproducts. If your water contains these contaminants, this pitcher is still worth considering, especially if you currently rent or don’t want to install a filtration system.
But if you’re mainly concerned about chlorine and heavy metals, you may as well buy a cheaper pitcher that offers these basic capabilities at a fraction of the price. That’s why we strongly recommend testing your water first: you won’t benefit from paying extra for a pitcher that claims to remove hundreds of contaminants if the majority of those aren’t even present in your water.
If you like the Clearly Filtered brand and are able to install a filter directly into your plumbing, the Clearly Filtered Under Sink Direct Connect is worth considering. It received a higher overall score of 9.18 in our testing and delivers water on demand when you turn on the faucet, so it’s a faster filtration solution than the pitcher.
❔ Clearly Filtered FAQs
Q: Did the Clearly Filtered pitcher’s score change after your second test?
A: Yes. The Clearly Filtered pitcher scored 8.78/10 in our first lab test in 2024 and 8.01/10 after our second and third lab tests, completed in July 2026. The Tap Score health score for our filtered water fell from 83 to 73, our measured filtration rate fell from 2.27 GPH to 0.97 GPH, free shipping now requires an autoship subscription, and the pitcher’s NSF/ANSI Standard 53 certification for PFOA and PFOS lapsed in the interim.
Q: Does Clearly Filtered remove PFAS?
A: Clearly Filtered claims greater than 99.5% PFOS and greater than 99.0% PFOA reduction based on manufacturer-commissioned third-party testing. When we first reviewed this pitcher, it held certification to NSF/ANSI Standard 53 for both, but that certification is no longer listed with WQA or NSF. We have not tested this pitcher for PFAS ourselves because our Tap Score panel does not include PFAS analytes, so we have no first-party data on this claim.
Q: Is the Clearly Filtered pitcher certified?
A: Partially. The Clearly Filtered pitcher is WQA and NSF certified to NSF/ANSI Standard 42 for chlorine taste and odor reduction, which is its only certified contaminant reduction claim, and to NSF/ANSI Standard 372 for lead-free materials. Standard 372 covers what the pitcher is made of, not what it removes. The manufacturer’s remaining 364+ reduction claims rest on third-party testing by QFT, a division of IAPMO, rather than certification.
Q: What was the cobalt result in your testing?
A: In all three of our lab tests, cobalt was not detected in our unfiltered water but was detected in the filtered water: 0.0054 PPM in 2024, 0.0159 PPM in our first 2026 test, and 0.0079 PPM in our second 2026 test, which used a new, just-purchased filter rather than one that had been in storage. Tap Score’s health-based screening level for cobalt is 0.002 PPM. We have not been able to determine the cause. Clearly Filtered claims greater than 97.1% cobalt reduction.
Q: Did the Clearly Filtered pitcher remove fluoride in your testing?
A: Yes. The pitcher reduced fluoride in all three of our tests: from 1.1 PPM to non-detect in 2024, from 1.0 PPM to non-detect in our first 2026 test, and from 1.7 PPM to 0.3 PPM (an 82.35% reduction) in our second 2026 test. The 2024 and first 2026 feed concentrations were close enough to compare directly; the second 2026 test started from a higher concentration.
Q: Does the Clearly Filtered pitcher remove lead?
A: Yes, in the one test where lead was present. In our first 2026 test, lead was detected at 0.0044 PPM in our unfiltered water and was non-detect after filtration, a 100% reduction. Our 2024 feed water and our second 2026 feed water contained no detectable lead, so those tests could not evaluate this claim.
Q: How fast does the Clearly Filtered pitcher filter water?
A: We measured a filtration rate of 0.97 gallons per hour (GPH), which works out to about 31 minutes for a full 63-ounce reservoir. That made it the second slowest of the 7 pitchers we tested in 2026, ahead of only the Epic Pure XP at 0.76 GPH. In our 2024 test of the previous design, we measured 2.27 GPH.
Q: How much does the Clearly Filtered pitcher cost to run?
A: Replacement filters cost $55.00 and are rated for 100 gallons, which gives a cost per gallon of $0.55. If you filter 1 gallon per day, you will use around 3.7 filters per year, which costs an estimated $200.75 per year, or $1,003.75 over five years. The pitcher itself costs $100 upfront.
Q: Clearly Filtered Pitcher vs Clearly Filtered Under Sink: which should you buy?
A: The Clearly Filtered Under Sink Direct Connect scored 9.18/10 in our testing, ahead of the pitcher’s 8.01/10, and delivers filtered water on demand from your cold water line. We recommend the under sink system if you can install at your plumbing, especially given the pitcher’s 0.97 GPH filtration rate. Choose the pitcher if you rent, move often, or want a no-install option.
Found this review helpful?
Comment below or share this article!
