The Best Hard Water Shower Filter for Renters

If you rent an apartment and deal with hard water, you already know the struggle:

Dry, itchy skin no matter how much moisturizer you use. 

Hair that feels like straw.

Soap that refuses to lather.

And the worst part is that you can’t just install a water softener like a homeowner would. Hard water shower filter options are ridiculously limited, so you’re stuck with the effects of hard water forever, right?

…Or are you?

What if I told you there’s a way to soften your shower water without breaking your lease, invasive installation or spending thousands on a whole-home system?

Most renters have no idea this solution even exists—but once you know about it, you’ll wonder how you ever lived without it.

The Hard Water Struggle

You probably feel the effects of hard water every day—but what actually makes water “hard”? In simple terms, it has high levels of dissolved minerals like calcium and magnesium, which it picks up as it moves through the ground. When you shower, these minerals react with soap, making it harder to rinse off and leaving a sticky residue on your skin and hair.

That’s why your skin feels dry and itchy no matter what lotion you use. And why your hair gets brittle, frizzy, and prone to breakage.

And it’s not just annoying—it’s scientifically proven to be damaging. 

One study found that hard water actually weakens hair, making it more likely to break. Another linked hard water exposure to increased risk of eczema, especially in children. And research suggests it can even disrupt your skin’s natural barrier, making it more susceptible to infection and irritation caused by bacteria.

So, how do you fix it?

The most effective solution is to soften your water with a water softener, which removes hardness minerals through a process called ion exchange. But here’s the problem: those systems are big, expensive, and require making permanent alterations to your plumbing.

If you’re renting, you can see why this isn’t a feasible option.

That’s why so many people turn to shower filters—which is often a big mistake. See, manufacturers love to claim that their filters soften water, but I tested nine of the most popular shower filters, and guess what? 

When I ran my own lab tests, the results were crystal clear: these filters did nothing to reduce water hardness.

Apartment Hard Water Shower Filter Solutions

So does that mean all these point-of-use shower filters are out? Pretty much. 

I did find one shower filter that actually softened my water—the Shower Stick—because it uses ion exchange resin, just like a traditional softener.

But would I recommend it? Nope.

Its tiny capacity means you’ll be constantly regenerating it, especially if you have really hard water, and the process is a pain. You have to run through multiple tedious steps to mix up a saltwater solution and carefully pour it into the unit.

Plus, from a safety perspective, its PVC housing likely contains plasticizers linked to potential health risks. And at nearly $300, you’d expect something better than the flimsy handheld showerhead it comes with.

So, what’s the better solution?

A Portable RV Water Softener

These systems work exactly like a conventional water softener, also using ion exchange to remove hardness minerals. 

But unlike whole-home softeners, they’re compact, easy to set up, and don’t require permanent installation. And unlike the Shower Stick, they have a much larger capacity, meaning you won’t be regenerating them every few days. 

When you do need to regenerate, it’s way simpler—just drain it, add salt directly to the unit’s wide-mouth opening, rinse, and you’re done.  No mixing solutions, no tedious pouring.

One of the most popular options—and the one I personally tested—is the On The Go portable softener. 

They wanted to give my readers 20% off, get your coupon code here

Depending on your water hardness, it can soften between 275 to 3,200 gallons before needing a regen.

It also gives you more flexibility. Instead of forcing you to use one they provide, you can use any showerhead you like but the setup is easiest with a handheld showerhead (more below).

And here’s the kicker: at $260, it’s actually cheaper than the Shower Stick, despite offering the same softening performance and lasting much longer between regenerations.

Now, of course it’s not perfect—it’s bulky and you’ll need to find a place for it. 

You can either keep it inside the shower itself, or on the floor outside, but you may need to run a longer hose for this setup. Not ideal, but a small price to pay for actual soft water. So if you’re tired of dealing with dry skin, frizzy hair, and soap that refuses to lather—this is by far the best option for apartment renters.

How to Soften Shower Water (the renter friendly way)

Alright, now I’m going to show you step by step how easy it is to set up, and you’ll just need a few extra parts to make it work:

• Two ¾-inch to ½-inch male connectors, to connect the softener to the shower hoses
• A handheld showerhead – I used this Moen Engage Magnetix one
• And an extra shower hose – I used this one, also from Moen

And if you really want to protect your softener and improve your water quality, I highly recommend adding a high-performance shower filter upstream. 

I used the Weddell Duo, the top performing shower filter in my testing, which removes not only chlorine, but also sediment and the more concerning disinfection byproducts commonly found in city water.

Step-by-Step Installation

1. First, I removed the plastic connectors that come with the softener and replaced them with ¾-inch to ½-inch stainless steel connectors. This step is key for making it compatible with standard shower hoses.
2. Next, I installed the handheld showerhead bracket onto the shower arm. Since I also wanted to use a filter, I attached the Weddell Duo here which I found to be the best spot because it keeps it out of the way. But if your space is tight, you can install it at the softener’s inlet instead.
3. I hooked up the inlet hose from the shower arm, well actually the Weddell Filter,  to the softener,
4. Then ran the outlet hose from the softener to the showerhead. 

And that’s it! It’s actually pretty simple and you don’t need to be a DIY expert. No drilling, no permanent changes, and instant soft water every time you shower.

Test Results and Benefits

So like I usually do, I wanted to get some data for you guys about the actual performance of this thing.

I used test strips and a titration test to measure my water hardness before and after installing the softener. 

My untreated water measured at 5 grains per gallon of hardness, putting it in the “moderately hard” category.

After treatment, both tests indicated zero grains per gallon, so my water had been completely softened with all minerals removed.

So what does that actually mean for your shower experience? Well, soft water helps your skin retain moisture, meaning less dryness, irritation, or that tight, itchy feeling. Your hair should feel softer, look shinier, and be easier to manage—since it’s no longer coated in minerals. Soap and shampoo lather better and rinse off completely, so you’re not left with that sticky film on your skin.

And while it’s probably not your top priority but still worth a mention, your shower itself should be easier to clean, with fewer water spots and less soap scum buildup. 

Conclusion and Recommendation

So if you’re tired of dealing with the effects of hard water but your rental situation rules out traditional softeners, a portable RV softener is the most practical and effective solution.

In our testing the On The Go softener completely eliminated water hardness using the most effective ion exchange process, delivering the same results as a full-size softener without the hassle of a permanent installation.

It also requires far less maintenance than the Shower Stick, making it a much more convenient option.

Now there are plenty of portable RV water softeners on the market, and they all function and look pretty much the same. I chose to test the On The Go Double Standard model because of its high 16,000-grain capacity, durable US-made construction, and user-friendly screw-top design that makes regeneration quick and easy.

They wanted to give my readers 20% off, get your coupon code here