If you’re looking for a pitcher that can filter your drinking water, you’ve probably come across the
Why should you trust this review? It’s my job to test and review water filters, so you don’t have to. As well as writing for WaterFilterGuru, I’m a contributing author at key water industry publications, like WWD Magazine and WQP magazine.
If a product doesn’t live up to customer expectations, I’ll work out why. And if something is worth the hype, I’ll delve into why people love it so much. You can count on me to deliver the facts, with the occasional honest opinion that you won’t get from a biased brand.
In this guide, I’ll be comparing the
While both pitcher filters are two of the higher performing on the market, we recommend Clearly Filtered as our top pick due to it’s mind blowing contaminant reduction capability.
However if you are looking for a pitcher filter that can also increase pH/alkalinity, then the Seychelle pH20 pitcher is the better option.
Table of Contents
⚖️ Comparison Chart
💡 Filter Comparison
Clearly Filtered Filters
First, water is sent through a mesh screen made from woven stainless steel. This sediment pre-filter traps larger particles and prevents clogging of the later filter stages.
Next, water flows through a loose filtration layer of granulated activated coconut carbon. This filter traps impurities that can affect water’s taste and smell, like chlorine.
The final layer is a composite shell filter, and consists of more than 7 proprietary filtration materials. This slows down water flow and gives it a longer contact time with the media, allowing for the most thorough filtration.
There’s no information on the Seychelle website on exactly what its pitcher filters are made from. This makes it difficult to compare the filter media to the material used in the
However, we do know that the Seychelle is made in the USA, and has been tested both nationally and internationally for contaminant removal.
The filter is designed for use with chlorinated city water, which suggests it is made from activated carbon or a similar type of carbon media. You can’t use the filter to treat saltwater.
As well as aesthetic contaminants like chlorine, this filter can remove chemicals, radiological contaminants and inorganic contaminants.
🧫 What Contaminants Do They Remove?
The Clearly Filtered pitcher is the best choice for contaminant reduction. This pitcher can reduce more than 360 harmful contaminants, including lead, chlorine, fluoride, BPA, and PFOS.
A big bonus is that, despite this thorough contaminant reduction, this filter still retains healthy minerals like calcium and magnesium. Not only do our bodies need these minerals to function, but they also give water a pleasant alkaline taste.
There’s no data on exactly how many contaminants the Seychelle pitcher can remove in advance – although the filter has been tested to remove 99.99% of several contamination “zones”, including aesthetic contaminants, inorganic contaminants, chemicals, and radiological impurities.
Here are the contaminants removed by both pitchers, as well as reduction rate:
|Contaminant||Clearly Filtered Reduction %||Seychelle Pitcher Removal %|
|*346 Additional Contaminants||Varies||Not Tested|
🚦 Performance Comparison
Considering how many contaminants the
There are several features that aid the filter’s performance and make the pitcher easier to use. The oversized grip handle simplifies pouring, and the water dam in the top reservoir stops water from leaking out of the lid or mixing with unfiltered water when you pour from the pitcher.
It would be ideal if the
Because the Seychelle pitcher has dual filters, it also overcomes the common pitcher drawback of slow filtration. Having two filters per system speeds up the flow rate, allowing the pitcher to filter water at double the speed. It takes about 7.5 minutes for half a gallon of water to get filtered.
If sediment and silt build up in the filters, you can flush them to improve flow rate and prevent a slow-down of filtration.
Despite its fast flow rate, the Seychelle pitcher still doesn’t match up to the
💲 Models & Upfront Cost
Clearly Filtered Models
You can buy just one type of
A 10-cup pitcher is a good size for most couples and families, as, even with heavier use, it will only require filling several times. Anything bigger than a 10-cup capacity and you may struggle to carry the filter when it’s full.
There are three Seychelle filter models available:
- Seychelle Gen 2 Dual pH2O Pure Water Pitcher (64oz)
- Seychelle Gen 2 Dual Regular Water Pitcher (64oz)
- 64 oz Radiological Water Pitcher
The difference between the two Gen 2 pitchers is that the pH20 filter increases water’s pH up to 9. The Regular pitcher doesn’t offer this benefit.
For the extra perks of the pH20 filter, it costs $10 more – $69.95, compared to the Regular pitcher’s cost of $59.95.
The Radiological pitcher is said to be the most technologically advanced of its kind. As the name suggests, it can remove more radiological contaminants than the Gen 2 pitchers, including gross beta, alpha radium 226, uranium, and cesium 137 & 134.
Because of its additional contaminant removal, the radiological pitcher is the priciest Seychelle offering, at $79.95. However, if you have a reason to be concerned about radiological contaminants in your area, this is still an affordable means of tackling the problem.
All three of the Seychelle pitchers have slightly smaller holding capacities than the
📆 Filter Lifespan & Replacement Costs
You can get 100 gallons out of a single
Choosing to buy filters in packs of three or more will help you to save money, as the cost per filter is lower than it is when you buy a single filter.
The average person will go through three
While this cost is more expensive than the Seychelle filters (see below), the
The cost of replacement filter cartridges for the Seychelle depends on which pitcher you have.
The Regular pitcher has the most basic filter cartridge, which removes the fewest contaminants of the three. You can buy a dual pack of these filters for $39.95. Remember, the Seychelle pitchers use two filters per pitcher, so you should use both of these at once. There’s no option to buy more filters for a greater discount.
The pH20 filter costs $49.95 for a pack of two, and the Radiological Water Pitcher’s filters cost $44.95. Again, you don’t get a discount for buying these filters in bulk.
💬 Customer Reviews & Complaints
Reviewers say that they’re happy with the
Clearly Filtered‘s impressive contaminant reduction abilities, with many also mentioning that their filtered water had a great taste, and that the pitcher works quickly to filter water.
One complaint was that the pitcher handle isn’t as well-built as it could be, and that the price of the pitcher and replacement filters is expensive. Others mentioned that they would like
Some customers said that the filter life was a lot shorter than advertised. It’s worth noting that filter life can be significantly shorter if your water contains more contaminants than the water the
Customers are happy with the quality of filtration offered by the Seychelle filters. Reviewers mentioned that the pH20 filter does a good job at increasing alkalinity.
However, customers mentioned that the pH20 filter doesn’t increase water’s alkalinity for long, and that there are better alternatives if boosting alkalinity is your goal. Some customers were also unimpressed with the price of the replacement filters, and some remarked that filtration speed was slower than they expected.
The alkalinity issue was the cause of most negative reviews, but one customer wrote that allowing the filter to sit in the water causes the pH to drop quickly, while filling the water below the filter helps to keep the filter working in the long term. It would be helpful if Seychelle mentioned this, or amended this issue with the filter.
☑️ Pros and Cons of
Clearly Filtered vs Seychelle
Clearly Filtered – What I Like
- Retains water’s natural minerals – Despite reducing more than 360 contaminants, the
Clearly Filteredretains water’s healthy minerals, like calcium and magnesium. These minerals give water a more pleasant alkaline taste.
- Good filter life – You can get up to 4 months of filtration out of the
Clearly Filtered‘s filters before you need to replace them. This is better than the average pitcher filter life of around 2 months.
- Reduces 360+ contaminants – The
Clearly Filteredpitcher can reduce more contaminants than any other pitcher filter on the market – more than 360 in total.
- Fast filtration – It’s common for filter pitchers to offer a slow filtration process, as they use gravity to filter water. However, the
Clearly Filteredis impressively speedy for a filter of its kind.
- Good value for money – While the
Clearly Filteredis one of the more expensive filters available, it’s still a good value for money when you consider the filter performance.
Clearly Filtered – What I Didn’t Like
- Only one filter style available – While the Seychelle pitcher has three types of filters to choose from, the
Clearly Filteredonly has one. You may prefer to choose from different filter options at different prices.
- Expensive to replace the filters – You’ll need to spend more per filter when replacing the
Clearly Filteredfilters. It will set you back $135 per year, minimum, on filter changes if you want to use the pitcher every day.
- Not actually NSF certified – The
Clearly Filteredpitcher has been tested to meet NSF standards, but it doesn’t have an actual NSF certification, which would be more reassuring.
👍 Seychelle – What I Like
- Multiple filter types available – You can choose between the Seychelle’s Regular, pH20 and Radiological filters, depending on what you want to remove from your water and the budget you have.
- More affordable – The Seychelle pitcher and replacement filters are more affordable than the
Clearly Filtered. If you have a smaller budget, you may want to spend less on the Regular pitcher filter.
- Optional remineralization – You can choose the pH20 filter if you’re interested in increasing your water’s pH as well as removing contaminants.
👎 Seychelle – What I Didn’t Like
- Slow filtration – Some customers said that the Seychelle took a long time to filter their water, especially for a pitcher that uses two filters.
- No NSF certification – Like the
Clearly Filtered, the Seychelle doesn’t have an NSF certification – it has just been tested to NSF standards.
- Not as good value for money – None of the Seychelle’s filters remove as many contaminants as the
Clearly Filtered, yet it’s still quite costly for a pitcher filter. Its value for money can’t compete with the Clearly Filtered.
- Potential design issue with pH20 filter – Many customers mentioned that you can’t fill the Seychelle pH20 pitcher to allow water to touch the filters, as this can prevent the filters from alkalizing the water.
❔ Should I Buy
Clearly Filtered or Seychelle?
Ultimately, if you’re looking for the best water filter pitcher for your home, the Clearly Filtered is the better option. It can reduce hundreds more contaminants than any of the Seychelle filters, with a similar filter lifespan. It can also filter water surprisingly quickly for a filter of its kind.
Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher
At the moment, no other pitcher filter reduces as many contaminants as the
That’s not to say that the Seychelle pitcher is incapable. You may prefer this filter, especially the radiological filter, if you need to remove specific contaminants from your water. The Seychelle is also more affordable (though whether that makes it a better value for money is another thing). But for general, all-round contaminant reduction from a brand you can trust, I recommend the